17 Popular Makeup Products Under $5

Introduction

I’m the first to admit that my makeup collection is constantly growing. Cosmetics are a huge passion of mine, but living frugally is equally important to me. That’s why finding the best cheap makeup makes me feel elated! And I’m more than happy to share these deals with you.

In this post, you’ll find 17 makeup products that cost $5 or less. I’ve based these picks on A) reviews from buyers, B) popularity in online beauty communities and C) products I’ve personally tried. If you want to find some excellent makeup that’s incredibly affordable, check out the list below.

Note: Keep in mind that these prices are subject to change, but at the time of writing they were $5 or less.

Best Cheap Eye Makeup

1. e.l.f. Cosmetics Eyebrow Kit

elf eyebrow kit makeup under $5

About The Product

The e.l.f. Cosmetics Eyebrow Kit is the first eyebrow product I used after it was recommended to me in a beauty forum. This duo contains a rich eyebrow gel and a brow powder to define and fill your brows.

It also comes with a mini brush that features a super precise double-sided brush. I highly recommend this product for anyone who wants an affordable way to get beautiful looking eyebrows!

Price Comparison

This highly-rated e.l.f. Cosmetics brow product is just $3.00! Compare that to the Urban Decay Brow Box, which is fairly similar and costs $9.00. You can get a great product while saving yourself $6.

Get it Here


2. NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil

cheap makeup under $5 nxy eye pencils

About The Product 

This two-in-one eye pencil doubles as an eyeliner and eyeshadow. From jet black to shimmery gold, you can choose from over 30 different colors.

This best-selling NYX item has a 4.5-rating and more than 300 excellent reviews on their website. I personally love these eye pencils, and I also use them for highlighting my brow bone and as an eyeshadow base. That’s four uses for a single product!

Price Comparison

These popular eye pencils are only $4.50 each. The Sephora Collection Colorful Shadow and Liner, a very similar product, cost $14 each. You can save $9.50 by going with the NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil.

Get it Here


3. Essence Make Me Brow Eyebrow Gel Mascara

cheap makeup under $5 essence eyebrow mascara

About The Product

Make Me Brow is a lightweight gel formula with tiny fibers to help fill in sparse eyebrows. The precision-style wand makes it easy to create fuller, defined brows in just seconds. This is a bestselling Essence product, and I’ve used it myself. It’s a great find if you want a simple way to tame your eyebrows!

Price Comparison

Make Me Brow retails for a mere $2.99 at Ulta. Compare that to Anastasia Beverly Hills, which has a slightly lower rating and retails for $22. Keep $19.01 in your wallet by purchasing the beloved Make Me Brow instead.

Get it Here


4. Wet n’ Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow Collection

wet n wild eyeshadow collection makeup under $5

About The Product

Wet n’ Wild is well known for having incredibly affordable yet quality cosmetics. These eyeshadow palettes are no exception! They each contain eight colors that are pearlescent and very pigmented.

There are three palettes to choose from, and each of them has an excellent selection of color. This product is very highly-rated, and ‘Comfort Zone’ is often recommended in beauty forums I frequent.

Price Comparison

The Wet n’ Wild Color Icon palette is just $4.99 for eight eyeshadows. Compare that to the Cargo Contour Eyeshadow Palette; it’s $28.00 and has a rating of 2.6 stars at Ulta.com. You can get a similar palette with better ratings while saving $23.01.

Get it Here


5. e.l.f. Cosmetics Studio Lengthening & Volumizing Mascara

elf lengthening mascara makeup under $5

About The Product

e.l.f. Is one of my favorite budget beauty brands, and I’m a big fan of this mascara. It looks natural and clump-free, but it really enhances the look of your eyelashes. The formula provides ample thickness, fullness, and length. The large mascara wand makes it easy to coat every single lash, too.

Price Comparison

This popular and highly-rated mascara costs $3. It’s comparable to the Sephora Collection Lashcraft Length & Volume Mascara, which costs $12.00. By purchasing e.l.f. Lengthening & Volumizing Mascara, you save yourself $9.

Get it Here


6. Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara

ulta lash princess mascara makeup under $5

About The Product

Essence Lash Princess Mascara is designed to give you dramatic looking eyelashes. The formula is volumizing and creates a false lash look that’s full and sultry.

This budget friendly product has a 4.5-star rating on Ulta’s website and over 400 reviews. It’s certainly a popular – and super affordable – mascara!

Price Comparison

Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara only costs $4.99 at Ulta. Let’s compare that to Tarte Best In Faux Lash Extending Fibers mascara. It’s a whopping $20.00 and has pretty poor reviews. Save $15.01 and get a product that’s less expensive and higher quality.

Get it Here


7. Wet n’ Wild MegaLiner Liquid Liner

wet n wild megaliner makeup under $5

About The Product

Liquid eyeliner can really make or break an eye makeup look, so having a high-quality formula and wand is important. Wet n’ Wild MegaLiner Liquid Liner is widely hailed as a super pigmented and long-lasting eyeliner, and I have to agree.

Despite being super cheap, it holds up better than brands that cost three or four times as much. The fine tipped brush makes it easy to create thin or thick lines, so you can create diverse styles.

Price Comparison

On Amazon,  Wet n’ Wild MegaLiner Liquid Liner costs right around $4.75. I’ll compare it to MAC Liquidlast Liner, which also has a super-fine tip. The major difference is that it costs a whopping $20. Try out the Wet n’ Wild option to save yourself about $15.25.

Get it Here

Best Cheap Face Makeup

8. e.l.f. Cosmetics Studio Blush

elf blush makeup under $5

About The Product

This silky smooth blush is one of my favorite products; I have it in at least five different colors. The lightweight texture of the blush makes the color very buildable.

You can give yourself a super subtle look or go for dramatically highlighted cheekbones. There are shimmer options and glitter options available, so you can choose whichever one suits your taste.

Price Comparison

The e.l.f. Cosmetics Studio Blush is only $3.00. This product is often compared to NARS Blush, which is another pressed powder blush. The NARS Blush cost a whopping $30. You can save yourself $27.00 if you order the e.l.f. Option instead.

Get it Here


9. Wet n’ Wild Coverall Correcting Palette

wet n wild coverall palette makeup under $5

About The Product

The Wet n’ Wild Coverall Correcting Palette was the first color correcting concealer I used, and it did not disappoint me one bit! It contains four colors, and each one has a unique purpose.

Green is used to conceal redness and blemishes, purple is used to cover up yellow areas, yellow is used for under-eye circles and other dark spots, and white is a subtle highlighter. The creamy formula is super easy to blend, and the palette has everything you need!

Price Comparison

The Wet n’ Wild Coverall Correcting Palette is a mere $3.99 on the brand’s website. I couldn’t find another palette with the exact same colors, but similar drugstore options cost between $10 and $15. The Wet n’ Wild palette covers all of your bases, and it’ll save you about $6 to $11.

Get it Here


10. Rimmel London Natural Bronzer

rimmel natural bronzer makeup under $5

About The Product

Rimmel London Natural Bronzer is designed to give your skin a sheer, warm glow that looks truly natural. The waterproof formula is made from fine natural minerals, and it’s designed to be long-lasting.

It’s such a simple way to get the sunless tan that you desire. It comes in several different colors to match various skin tones. This product has overall positive feedback from satisfied Amazon buyers.

Price Comparison

Rimmel London Natural Bronzer costs right around $5.00. Compare that to Too Faced Sunny Bunny Natural Bronzer that costs $30. Get the healthy glow that you crave while saving $25.

Get it Here


11. Rimmel Stay Matte Pressed Powder

rimmel stay matte makeup under $5

About The Product

Rimmel Stay Matte Pressed Powder is a holy grail product for me, and Amazon buyers have the same opinion! This powder is perfect for oily skin; it lasts all day long and has a natural finish.

I wear it with or without foundation to keep my skin shine-free. One pan of it lasts several months, so you can really get your money’s worth!

Price Comparison

Rimmel Stay Matte Pressed Powder is right around $3.50 on Amazon. Compare that to Sephora Collection Matte Perfection Powder, which costs $20. When you choose the super popular Rimmel option, you save $16.50.

Get it Here


12. e.l.f. Makeup Mist and Set

elf makeup mist and set makeup under $5

About The Product

Having makeup that lasts all day long is a must for many women. The e.l.f. Makeup Mist and Set Spray is designed to lock your makeup in place. The formula is lightweight and alcohol-free, so it’s pretty gentle on your skin.

It also contains aloe, cucumber, and green tea, so it has a subtle and refreshing scent that I love. This Amazon Best Selling item has over 1,600 reviews and very good feedback, too.

Price Comparison

e.l.f. Makeup Mist and Set is about $3.00 on Amazon. It’s very comparable to the ULTA Makeup Setting Spray, which costs $10.00. You can lock in your makeup with the e.l.f. option while saving yourself $7.00.

Get it Here


13. Wet n’ Wild MegaGlo Highlighting Powder

wet n wild highlighting powder makeup under $5

About The Product

Highlighter is an extremely trendy product these days, and Wet n’ Wild MegaGlo Highlighting Powder does not disappoint! This pearlescent powder has a fine natural shimmer to it, so it adds a subtle yet noticeable glow to your skin.

It’s available in two pinkish-gold hues, so you can choose the one that is right for you. On the Wet n’ Wild website, this beloved product has 92 ratings and most are five-star.

Price Comparison

Wet n’ Wild MegaGlo Highlighting Powder costs $4.99. Many reviewers compare it to high-end brands like BECCA Shimmering Skin Perfector, which cost a whopping $38.00. Get excellent results from the Wet n’ Wild highlighter while also saving $33.01.

Get it Here


14. Rimmel Lasting Finish Foundation

rimmel lasting finish foundation makeup under $5

About The Product

When it comes to long-lasting makeup, Rimmel Lasting Finish Foundation is an excellent pick. The unique and popular formula is designed to last up to 25 hours. It’s highly resistant to sweat, heat, humidity, and transferring.

It provides medium coverage, so you can maintain a flawless yet natural look. The formula is very easy to blend, which makes it ideal for covering up pores and imperfections. On Amazon, this beloved foundation has nearly perfect star ratings and glowing reviews.

Price Comparison

A bottle of Rimmel Lasting Finish Foundation costs about $4.80 on Amazon. The formula is pretty comparable to MAC Longwear Foundation, which costs $34.00 per bottle. Get the Rimmel foundation instead, and you’ll get great results while saving $29.20.

Get it Here

Best Cheap Lipstick and Lipgloss

15. NYX Slim Lip Pencils

About The Product

I consider lip liner an essential product, and NYX Slim Lip Pencils are my favorite pick. The formula is soft and buttery but firm enough to precisely line my lips.

The formula is also bleed resistant; I never have issues with it smudging or running off onto my skin. On the NYX website, the NYX Slim Lip Pencil has a 4.7-star rating and more than 300 reviews. You can choose from 50 unique colors to match your lipstick collection.

Price Comparison

These top-notch lip pencils are only $3.50 each. I find these pencils very comparable to MAC Lip Pencils, which cost $17.50 each. Buying the NYX Slim Lip Pencil will save you a whopping $14 per pencil.

Get it Here


16. NYX Butter Gloss

nxy butter gloss makeup under $5

About The Product

I’m normally not a fan of lip gloss, but NYX Butter Gloss completely won me over. The super smooth formula isn’t sticky at all, and the color payoff is excellent.

One layer creates a perfect sheer look, but it’s easily buildable if you want something builder. This NYX best selling item has a 4.8-star rating on their website, over 400 glowing reviews, and it’s available in 34 beautiful shades.

Price Comparison

NYX Butter Gloss is just $5.00 per tube on the NYX website. Compare that to Anastasia Beverly Hills lip gloss, which has a 4.4-star rating and costs $16 per tube. You can stock up on NYX Butter Gloss while saving yourself $11.

Get it Here


17. Rimmel London Lasting Finish By Kate Lipstick

rimmel london lasting lipstick makeup under $5

About The Product

Rimmel Lasting Finish Lipstick is designed by model Kate Moss, and this product has a lot to offer. It’s designed to last up to eight hours, and the formula is impressively pigmented.

I have this product in ‘04’, a deep purple hue; the finish is satiny smooth and even. Make sure to check out the 600+ excellent reviews this product has on Amazon.

Price Comparison

A tube of this high-quality lipstick costs about $5. It’s commonly considered a dupe for MAC Lipstick, which costs $17.00. You can snag yourself the Rimmel product, get great results, and save yourself $12.00.

Get it Here

Frugal Five Dollar Finds For Every Makeup Lover

As you can see, getting makeup for cheap doesn’t mean you’re sacrificing quality. These 17 items are highly-rated, popular, and incredibly budget friendly. From sleek eyeliner to luscious lipstick, you can buy a bit of everything for $5 or less. And when you compare these items to similar ones, you’re saving approximately $282.99.

We hope you enjoyed this article and found some gems to add to your makeup collection. If you want to save even more money on makeup, check out Top 20 Best Drugstore Foundations Under $20 and 20 Fashion and Beauty Sites That Offer Free Shipping. You can always look and feel fabulous while remaining frugal!

One Response

  1. Alina Mar 15, 2017

Leave a Reply