ThredUp Review: What Sellers Really Keep and What Buyers Should Check

This ThredUp review looks at an online thrift store that sells your used clothes for you and also lets you shop secondhand clothing for less.

Folded secondhand sweaters, a denim jacket and a striped shirt next to an empty mailing bag on a wooden floor

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This comes at no extra cost to you. Read our full disclosure, or see how we review platforms.

Quick Answer

ThredUp is a legit online thrift store that sells your used clothes and pays you a share of each sale price. The main catch is a $14.99 fee per bag taken from your earnings, so cheap clothes can pay very little.

Join ThredUp

This ThredUp review looks at an online thrift store that sells your used clothes for you and also lets you shop secondhand clothing for less.

ThredUp takes the photos, writes the listings and ships the orders when you sell.

That help has a price, though.

A $14.99 fee per bag comes out of your earnings, and you only get paid for clothes that actually sell.

This review covers how selling works, what it can pay, what the fees are and what buyers should check before they order.

I judged ThredUp on 4 things, using its fee and FAQ page, a seller forum thread and our review rules:

  • How easy it is to send in your clothes
  • What you keep after fees
  • How safe it is to buy from
  • How it compares with selling clothes yourself

Here are the key facts in one place:

ThredUp at a Glance
Best ForClearing out a closet with little work, if small payouts are fine
Cost to ShopFree, with no membership fee
Cost to Sell$14.99 per 30 lb bag, taken from earnings after items sell
PayoffA share of each item's sale price
Extra Options$10.99 to get rejected items back, $5.99 to reclaim an unsold item
Shop Size50,000 new items added every day
First StepRequest a Clean Out Kit

Most of what follows matters more to sellers than to buyers, since sellers are the ones who pay those fees.

How Does ThredUp Work?

ThredUp works as an online consignment store that sorts, photographs and lists the clothes you mail in. You get paid for the ones it accepts, once they sell.

ThredUp also runs the shop where those same secondhand clothes are sold.

According to ThredUp’s own reviews page, it is one of the world’s largest online thrift stores, with 50,000 new items added every day.

ThredUp help center section on selling with a Clean Out

That size helps both sides. A big shop brings lots of buyers to your clothes, and it gives shoppers a lot to choose from.

Sellers and buyers judge it on different things, though.

Shoppers mostly care about prices and condition. Sellers care about what is left after the fee, and that is where the complaints below come from.

In other words, ThredUp saves you the work of selling, and its fee is what you pay for that help.

Here are ThredUp’s main pros and cons:

Pros

  • ThredUp photographs, lists and ships for you
  • No upfront cost to sell
  • Fee never goes past your earnings
  • Huge, fast-changing shop for buyers

Cons

  • You get paid only for items that sell
  • $14.99 fee per bag
  • Rejected clothes come back only for $10.99
  • Clothes are not washed before shipping

Is ThredUp Legit?

ThredUp is a legit company that sells real clothes and pays real sellers. Its weak spot is the payout, which some sellers say is not worth the effort.

You pay nothing up front to sell, because the fee comes out of what you earn.

Why do some people call it a ripoff, then?

Most of the anger comes from the gap between what an item sells for and what the seller gets. ThredUp pays based on the sale price, and its fee comes off the top, so cheap items can leave you very little.

In a YouLookFab forum thread from more than 10 years ago, one member said ThredUp paid for 6 of about 20 items she sent. Her payout averaged about $5 for each item it took.

YouLookFab forum thread where a member reviews her first ThredUp payout

Another member in the same thread said a very full bag of baby clothes paid about $12.

Those reports are old, so treat them as a few people’s results, not today’s rates.

In other words, ThredUp is real and it pays, but it pays like a consignment shop, not like selling the clothes yourself.

How Selling on ThredUp Works, Step by Step

Selling on ThredUp takes 4 steps on your side, and ThredUp handles the pricing, listing and shipping after your bag arrives. ThredUp’s FAQ says selling is free to get started.

Here’s the order to follow:

  1. Request a Clean Out Kit from ThredUp’s site.
  2. Decide whether you want rejected clothes back.
  3. Fill the bag with clean clothes and mail it.
  4. Wait for ThredUp to sort, photograph and list what it accepts.

Step 2 is the one people miss.

ThredUp lists a $10.99 option to have unaccepted items returned to you. The YouLookFab member said you had to choose that on your account before sending the bag, because once it was processed, it was too late.

Her post is old, so check that setting in your account before you ship.

Clean clothes matter too. ThredUp says it encourages sellers to send in clean, ready-to-wear clothes.

Hands packing a folded cardigan into a mailing bag half full of clothes

After that, expect to wait. One forum member said ThredUp took 4 weeks to get back to her, so plan for weeks, not days.

In other words, decide what should happen to rejected clothes before the bag leaves your house.

How Much Does ThredUp Pay for Clothes?

ThredUp pays you a share of each item’s sale price, and only after that item sells, so the same bag can pay very different amounts. ThredUp then takes its $14.99 fee per bag out of those earnings.

What does that mean for you?

You don’t set the price on a ThredUp item, so you can’t know your payout ahead of time. ThredUp handles everything from pricing to shipping once you send your clothes in.

ThredUp help center article on what you might earn when selling

Here’s a made-up example to show how the fee works. Say 6 items from your bag sell, and your share adds up to $30.

The $14.99 fee leaves you with $15.01.

Now say your share only adds up to $10. ThredUp says it won’t charge you the difference, so you get $0 and owe nothing.

The real numbers from sellers have been small too. The forum results above, about $5 an item and about $12 for a full bag, came from more than 10 years ago.

Cashing out was slower than spending, according to the same YouLookFab member. She could spend her payout on ThredUp right away, but cashing out to PayPal meant a two-week wait.

Before you send a bag, check the current earnings chart on ThredUp’s site, since rates can change.

In other words, the more an item sells for, the more you keep, and cheap items can disappear into the fee.

What Fees Does ThredUp Charge Sellers?

As of November 2026, ThredUp charges sellers a $14.99 fee per 30 lb-capacity bag, taken from earnings after items sell. ThredUp never bills you for more than you earned, and it says the fee covers inspection, photos, shipping and returns.

Two other charges are optional:

  • $10.99 to have unaccepted items returned to you
  • $5.99 to reclaim an unsold item, plus return shipping

The reclaim fee is for one unsold item, so getting several pieces back adds up fast.

ThredUp help center article explaining how its seller fees work

Here’s the deal: if you’d be happy to donate whatever doesn’t sell, skip both options and keep more of your money. ThredUp also lets you donate items for a charitable cause, according to its FAQ.

In other words, the $14.99 fee is the one you always face, and the extras only apply if you want clothes back.

What Happens to Clothes ThredUp Doesn’t Accept?

Clothes ThredUp doesn’t accept come back to you only if you choose the $10.99 return option before your bag is processed. Without it, the old forum report says it was too late to get them back.

ThredUp can be picky. The forum seller who was paid for 6 of about 20 items said it was clear the company does not take everything.

That pickiness is worth planning around. If a piece could sell well on its own, you may do better listing it yourself than mailing it in.

ThredUp help center article on items that aren’t accepted or don’t sell

Clothes that ThredUp accepts but can’t sell are a separate case. ThredUp lists a $5.99 fee to reclaim an unsold item, plus return shipping.

In other words, only send clothes you are ready to let go of, unless you pay for the return option.

Is ThredUp Trustworthy to Buy From?

ThredUp is safe to buy from in the basic sense, since shopping is free and you pay only the item price and shipping. ThredUp’s FAQ also says there is no membership fee, and items are inspected for quality and cleanliness.

The bigger risk is fit.

The YouLookFab member said ThredUp didn’t always give garment measurements, so she had to guess from past experience with a brand. Her post is more than 10 years old, but checking measurements before you buy is still a smart habit.

Here’s who should be careful:

  • Shoppers between sizes: compare listed measurements with a piece you already own.
  • Fans of one brand: stick to brands whose sizing you know well.
  • Anyone buying a gift: a used item’s condition matters more when you can’t try it on first.

If you mainly want cheap new clothes, compare these budget clothing sites too.

ThredUp’s Return Policy

ThredUp’s return rules can change, so read its current returns page before you order anything you might send back. More than 10 years ago, the YouLookFab member reported a 14-day return window and said handbags could not be returned at all.

ThredUp help center article explaining its return policy

Treat that as history, not as today’s policy.

If free shipping matters to you, this list of sites that offer free shipping can help you compare.

In other words, ThredUp is safe to order from, but check sizes and the current return rules before you pay.

Does ThredUp Wash Its Clothes?

No, ThredUp does not wash clothes before it ships them, but it inspects each item for quality and cleanliness, according to its FAQ. ThredUp itself suggests washing items before you wear them.

That advice is worth following for anything secondhand.

Check the care label first, since some pieces need a gentle cycle or dry cleaning.

Hands washing a secondhand wool sweater in a sink of soapy water

In other words, plan to wash every ThredUp order before you wear it.

Is ThredUp Worth It for Sellers?

ThredUp is worth it for sellers who want a closet cleared with little work and would otherwise donate the clothes. It is a poor choice for valuable pieces you could sell yourself.

The $14.99 fee per bag decides a lot of that.

Here’s who it suits:

  • Busy people: you send one bag, and ThredUp does the photos, listings and shipping.
  • Donors at heart: anything that earns a few dollars is a bonus over giving it away.
  • Big clean-outs: one 30 lb bag holds a lot of clothes for the same $14.99 fee.

The best part?

You never pay more than you earn, so a bad bag costs you time and shipping effort, not cash.

Selling yourself is the other path. In the same YouLookFab thread, one member sold 19 items on eBay for just over $500.

That was more than 10 years ago, and it took her time to photograph and post each item. Still, it shows what setting your own prices can bring in.

Clothes sorted into three piles on a rug, with one pile in an open donation bag

For more ideas, this guide on how to sell almost anything you own covers clothes and much more. You can also look at these things you can sell fast when you need cash this week.

In other words, ThredUp is worth it for low-value clothes and limited time, not for your best pieces.

ThredUp vs. Poshmark: Which Is Better?

Poshmark is better if you want control over your price, and ThredUp is better if you want less work. On Poshmark, you list, price and ship each item yourself, as ThredUp’s own FAQ points out.

That means on Poshmark you take the photos and mail each item when it sells. On ThredUp, you mail one bag, and the company handles everything from pricing to shipping.

Why does that matter?

Control can mean more money per item, but it also means more hours. If you have a few name-brand pieces and some free evenings, Poshmark makes more sense.

Poshmark homepage, where sellers list and price their own clothes

If you have a closet full of everyday clothes and no time, ThredUp is the easier choice.

In other words, choose Poshmark for your best pieces and ThredUp for the rest.

ThredUp Alternatives Worth Comparing

ThredUp alternatives come in 2 kinds: apps where you sell each item yourself, such as Poshmark and eBay, and donating the clothes for free. Which one fits depends on how much time you have and how much the clothes are worth.

ThredUp alternatives

#SiteBest ForJoin
1PoshmarkSetting your own price on name-brand piecesJoin Now
2eBayListing items yourself, from clothes to almost anything elseJoin Now

On eBay, you list items yourself, the same way you would on Poshmark. Shoppers can also use these steps to save on eBay purchases when they buy secondhand.

Mercari is another do-it-yourself app, and it made our list of the best online flea markets.

Donating is the simplest choice of all. ThredUp lets you donate items for a charitable cause, and a local thrift store works too.

If selling clothes is one part of a bigger plan, browse these ways to make extra money or our other money app reviews.

Key Takeaways

  • It's legit. ThredUp is a real online thrift store that adds 50,000 new items every day.
  • The fee is fixed. You pay $14.99 per bag, but never more than you earn.
  • Payouts can be small. You get a share of the sale price, and only for items that sell.
  • Choose returns early. Getting rejected clothes back costs $10.99.
  • Wash what you buy. ThredUp inspects clothes but does not wash them.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does it cost money to sell on ThredUp?

Selling on ThredUp costs nothing up front, because the $14.99 fee per bag comes out of your earnings only after items sell. If your earnings are lower than the fee, ThredUp says you won’t be charged the difference.

Do you actually make money on ThredUp?

Yes, you make money on ThredUp when your accepted items sell, but the amounts are often small after the $14.99 bag fee. One forum seller, more than 10 years ago, averaged about $5 for each item ThredUp paid for.

Can you get your clothes back from ThredUp?

ThredUp returns clothes it doesn’t accept only if you choose its $10.99 return option. Getting back an accepted item that didn’t sell costs $5.99, plus return shipping.

How long does ThredUp take to process a bag?

ThredUp can take several weeks to process a Clean Out bag, based on seller reports. One forum member, more than 10 years ago, waited 4 weeks to hear back.

Is there a better option than ThredUp?

Poshmark or eBay is often a better option than ThredUp for clothes worth more than a few dollars, since you set the price yourself. ThredUp is the better option when you want the work done for you.

Who pays the highest for used clothes?

Selling clothes yourself can pay more than consignment, because you set the price instead of ThredUp. One forum member, more than 10 years ago, sold 19 items on eBay for just over $500.

The Bottom Line

ThredUp is a legit and easy way to clear out clothes. Its $14.99 bag fee and small payouts make it a poor way to earn real money, though.

Pick 10 everyday pieces you’d otherwise donate and request a Clean Out Kit this week. See what that first bag pays before you send your best clothes anywhere.

Jason Michaels
Written by Jason Michaels

Jason is a personal finance expert and the founder of Frugal For Less. He has spent over a decade researching and testing hundreds of money making apps, survey sites, and savings strategies to help readers earn more and keep more of their hard-earned cash.

More about the author
↑↓ to move Enter to open